Parenting Adolescents

Contact      CLICK HERE FOR no-fee ACCESS TO SITE

 

 

Littleton (Columbine High School) Commentary

The View from Abroad

by Kate Barkley*

avoiding polarization | Karen Martin commentary | Littleton bulletin board | book reviews on related topics

Thanks for drawing my attention to your Littleton analysis. It was really interesting to view it from my perspective here in France.

You know, we have a group of teenage boys here in town who seem to hang out at the bus stop an awful lot. They are just about the same age as were the neo-nazis who opened fire in Colorado.

I first noticed the boys in our town when I would walk Hannah at night and muse about the fact that, were a comparable group of boys to inhabit my life in a comparable way almost anywhere in the United States, I would not be walking my dog alone at night.

Text....

And while there was sadness, how could there not be?, most of the talk dealt with disbelief. And not the kind of disbelief that is really denial that anything so tragic could happen, but disbelief that Americans can let something like that happen.

Littleton as a culturally specific tragedy

My point is that Littleton was a very culturally specific tragedy, as American as the right to bear arms. The point you made about access to weaponry, I think, can not be emphasized too much. And I think that is especially important in terms of giving people something to do with their fear.

Work to make guns illegal and as inaccessible as possible. Compare violent death rates between the US and any other highly industrialized country. Then break the numbers down according to weapon. It doesn't take an Einstein to figure it all out.

"I know that neo-Nazism is a threat here as well as in the United States."
French teenagers watch violent movies, and play violent video games just like American teens. Still, one can't imagine that the same thing could happen here. And it is happening with twisted regularity in the US.

The biggest difference I see is in access to arms -- that and the attitude (in Europe) that the state has a responsibility towards its citizenry. Even in an area with a precarious agricultural economy and almost 20% unemployment, no one here questions that young people have the right to be entertained, listened to, and responded to by their government. (The United States is always so fond of pointing out that children don't have civil rights; it seems like such a concept when they do!)

Anyhow, I was obviously moved by what you wrote, and I was going to go to the Bulletin Board to post a response (last week), but we had friends visiting, and the computer is basically in the guest bathroom. But better late than never.... a la prochaine,

Kate Barkley. 5/2/99

*Kate Barkley holds a PhD in Sociology and is living in a small town in France with her husband and child. Visitors who wish to respond to this commentary are invited to post a message on the Bulletin Board. 

TOP OF PAGE

Go to TEEN POLL!

home page, or

Click here for no-fee access to full site

URL of this site: http://www.parentingadolescents.com

Last updated: 11/16/01 Copyright Karen Martin 10/98, all rights reserved.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Click Here!